For the true cheese aficionado, pizza isn’t just food; it’s a canvas where cheese is the star. At New York Pizza, the commitment to rich, gooey, and abundant cheese turns every pie into a decadent experience. If your heart beats for that perfect stretch, that savory melt, and that golden-brown blister, this curated list is your ultimate guide. Here are the 10 must-try pizzas at New York Pizza that celebrate cheese in all its glorious forms.

1. Creamy Pleasure

Living up to its name, this Creamy Pleasure pizza is a masterclass in creamy dairy delight. It features a lush, velvety cheese sauce as its base, often blended with mozzarella and creamy cheeses like ricotta or cream cheese, creating an indulgent, smooth, and extraordinarily cheesy foundation.

2. New York Special

A tribute to the classic, this New York Special pizza is all about the perfect cheese pull. Loaded with a generous double layer of 100% mozzarella on a signature tangy sauce, it’s the pure, unadulterated cheese experience that defines a true New York slice.

3. Creamy Ficato

This unique offering combines the savory punch of Creamy Ficato with a rich, creamy cheese blend. The sharpness of the meat is beautifully balanced by a blanket of melted, mild, and creamy cheeses, creating a complex and deeply satisfying flavor profile.

4. Chicken Brooklyn

Chicken Brooklyn, a hearty choice where seasoned chicken meets an avalanche of cheese. The combination of mozzarella and often a hint of cheddar over the juicy chicken ensures every bite is packed with savory, cheesy goodness.

5. Beef Pepperoni

A classic, amplified. The spicy, crispy edges of beef pepperoni cups trap pools of molten cheese and oil, creating tiny flavor explosions. The robust cheese layer here is crucial, standing up to the spice and saltiness perfectly.

6. Chicken Pepperoni

The best of both worlds. This chicken pepperoni pizza doubles the protein but, more importantly, doubles the cheese’s role as the unifying, rich agent that binds the savory chicken and zesty pepperoni together in perfect harmony.

7. Saucy BBQ Chicken

While BBQ sauce is the headline, cheese is the co-star that makes it sing. A thick layer of mozzarella melts into the sweet and smoky BBQ sauce and grilled chicken, creating a sticky, gooey, and irresistible combination. This Saucy BBQ is an outstanding option.

8. Houston Hot

This Houston Hot is for those who like it spicy and cheesy. The heat from the jalapeños and hot sauce is brilliantly cooled and complemented by a generous, melting cheese layer that soothes the palate while adding its own rich texture.

9. Downtown Ranch

A creamy dream. This Downtown Ranch pizza often features a ranch-based sauce or drizzle, which, when combined with a double cheese layer, creates an exceptionally moist, tangy, and decadently creamy cheese experience in every slice.

10. Chicken Peri Peri

The fiery Chicken Peri Peri marinade needs a strong, mild cheese counterpart to balance its heat. The ample mozzarella doesn’t just add texture; it’s a cooling, milky blanket that makes the vibrant spices more enjoyable and layered.

The Cheesy Verdict

At New York Pizza, cheese isn’t an afterthought, it’s the soul of the pizza. Whether you crave pure mozzarella bliss, creamy concoctions, or cheeses that masterfully balance bold toppings, there’s a pie waiting to become your new favorite. Your journey to cheesy nirvana starts here.